2022-01-28

Conceptual Knowledge vs. Nonconceptual Wisdom

I think I understand even more clearly now the fundamental limitations of linguistics and academic studies of Judaism and my concomitant total loss of interest in them. These limitations may also apply to other areas of intellectual occupations, which I haven't experienced directly (thus I prefer not to generalize). This is in sharp contrast with teachings and practices of nonduality, including Chabad Chassidus. This contrast can be summarized in one phrase as that between conceptual knowledge, which is limited by our linguistic faculty, which by nature is dualistic vs. nonconceptual wisdom, which transcends this linguistic duality.

The following is yet another rather contradictory attempt to explain the fundamental limitations of these dualistic occupations with the help of a dualistic tool called language.

The true, first-tier, reality of the universe seems to defy any attempts to understand it purely conceptually, especially using a language without being aware of its dualistic limitations.

Linguistics and academic studies of Judaism, among others, seem to occupy themselves with the second-tier reality instead. The moment we label something (or someone in this respect, too) linguistically without accompanying direct experiences, we distance ourselves maximally from the first-tier reality. In other words, the more conceptual knowledge we accumulate, the more distant we seem to become from nonconceptual understanding. We can spend our whole life trying to know as much as possible about honey, for example, but we can never fully know it unless we directly experience it, that is, taste it.

My conclusion so far after spending about four years studying Chabad Chassidus, partly in a formal setting and partly by myself, as well as other nondual teachings by myself is that by merely occupying ourselves with the second-tier reality we don't seem to be able to reach the first-tier reality, nor nonconceptual wisdom.

All the linguistic ideologies, including Yiddishism and Esperantism, which used to occupy me for more than three decades, as well as nondualistic religious dogmas seem to suffer from these fundamental limitations.

Unfortunately, few of these people, including linguists and scholars of Judaism, seem to be fully aware of these limitations. But on the other hand, one can also say that thanks to this unawareness of theirs they may still be able to occupy themselves with these academic and non-academic activities. As for me, I've already had enough to continue wasting my time. But I just want to stress here that this doesn't mean that I delegitimize these activities. They are not simply for me any more.

2022-01-14

Gratitude and Flow

"Acknowledging the good that is already in your life is the foundation for all abundance." - Eckhart Tolle

Every time someone asked me something to do for him or her and failed to acknowledge its receipt, I often used to feel offended and sometimes even complained directly to him or her. Luckily, I feel little or no resentment any more. I feel compassion instead now.

Especially when I was still teaching in the university, I used to receive many questions from my ex-students and quite a few others, including total strangers. I always answered - and still answer - them to the best of my knolwedge at my earliest convenience. Statistically speaking, less than one out of ten people expresses gratitude for the help he or she received from me. I don' take this personally any more. I'm quite sure those who don't do so to me don't "discriminate" people in this respect - they never express their gratitude to others for helping them, whether they asked such help explicitly or not.

Why do I feel compassion - and even deep one - for them? Because they don't seem to understand one important universal truth - gratitude is an important secret for flowing with the Divine energy instead of forcing yourself through the flow with your egoic will. I've encountered this seemingly unversal teaching about the importance of gratitude in various spiritual traditions, including Chabad Chassidus.

While feeling deep compassion for them, I seldom share this wisdom with those who fail to even acknowledge receipt of the help they received simply because they aren't ready yet to appreciate this universal truth.

In one area of my new professional activity I've had a unique opportunity to observe a close correlation among people I've helped help themselves between their habit of expressing gratitude and their seeming level of positive energy. This is a vicious circle for them - since they fail to express gratitude, they attract negative energy on the one hand, and since their energy is negative, they fail to express gratitude on the other.

Even many of those who do have this habit fail to express the most important kind of gratitude - gratitude for the life they are entrusted with every morning. When asked what his most favorite blessing was, the Lubavitcher Rebbe answered מודה אני. I also feel the same. I start my new day with this blessing:

- Hebrew original: מודה אני לפניך מלך חי וקיים, שהחזרת בי נשמתי בחמלה. רבה אמונתך.‏
- Ashkenazic pronunciation in transcription: moyde ani lefoneykho melekh khay vekayom, shehekhzarto bi nishmosi bekhemlo. rabo emunoseykho.
- English translation: I offer thanks to You, living and eternal King, for You have mercifully restored my soul within me. Your faithfulness is great.

Thank you very much for reading this blog entry.